This post was inspired by a recent conversation between a girl and a couple guys. The guys asked: “who is the uglier between these two (not present) guys?” The woman responded with: “well, this guy is physically uglier but he’s more attractive over all.” The guys broke out laughing before she even delivered her “but.” All they cared about was which guy was physically uglier, even though she said that the ugly guy is more attractive over all. The woman who spoke became confused because the men completely disregarded half of her opinion.
Males are often ridiculed for our judgement of, so called, “superficial traits” like physical female beauty. This conversation between a couple people made me realize that many women can not imagine men being attracted to primarily physicality instead of personality. They can not conceptualize such a world. Just like most men these days can not conceptualize a world where personality traits are primary. Women are primarily attracted to a set of behaviors and personalities. That’s why women tell one another, “Don’t worry you have a great personality. You’ll be successful in love sometime.” Women are imagining the sexual marketplace operating from their point of view only.
Their logic goes like this: “I am attracted to men -> men are attractive primarily because of various emotional characteristics -> therefor, women are also attractive because of various emotional characteristics, because men judge women by the same way women judge men -> Therefor, if I want to make myself attractive I must increase my character through work and extra-curriculars.” The logic in that reasoning is faulty. Even though there is faulty logic this is the reasoning my female friend was using. It led to her confusion over my male friend’s reaction. Men are not attracted to women for the same reason women are attracted to men. Men are guilty of the same faulty logic.
This is the logic from a man’s standpoint: “I am attracted to women -> women are attractive primarily because of their bodies -> therefor, men with better bodies have a huge edge over those who do not have good bodies because women judge men the same way men judge women -> So to increase my attractiveness I must work on my body.” Again, that logic is faulty. Women do not judge men the same way men judge women. Women do not judge men primarily by their bodies and men do not judge women primarily by their character.
Now, I’m not saying that masculine bodies and feminine behavior have no impact on attractiveness. I’m merely saying that both genders tend to pursue the wrong course of action when they try to make themselves attractive because they view attractiveness from their own genders standpoint. A lot of people seem to think that there is a one-size-fits-all plan for attractiveness that works for everybody in the world. Of course there is not.
For example, many women believe that careers and income play a large part in their attractiveness. When they are thinking this they are really applying a mental schema of attractiveness that applies to men. Careers and income are much more attractive on a man than a woman. So when an individual woman is having success in business without success in the dating world she become confused. She asks herself: “I’ve increased my value, why am I not having success with men?” My answer to her would be: because you have wrongly measured the impact a career has on your sexual attractiveness on the margin. The inverse of this is men who spend too much time on their bodies in pursuit of women. They achieve their ideal physique and then become disillusioned when they do not have the success they thought they would. It is because an attractive body is not as important for a male as it is for a female. Both individuals above are not making the best move to increase their attractiveness on the margin, even though they think they are. That leads to discontent when they don’t have the success in the dating market they think they deserve. That short term discontent leads to long term depression against the opposite sex. This has lead me to believe that the conflict-filled relations between genders in today’s society is coming from a deep seated selfishness and an inability to empathize with the other. Both genders are being selfish in that they are refusing to believe that the other gender has a sexual strategy that is different from, and equal to, their own.

